Most employers believe a broad PPO keeps them neutral: by not picking sides, they stay out of the business of steering anyone’s care. Here’s the uncomfortable truth we kept circling in this episode. If you’re not steering, someone else is doing it for you. 

For Episode 3, I sat down with Nick Stefanizzi, CEO of Northwell Direct, and Todor Penev, who leads US Health Analytics at Aon, on a question that sounds dry and turns out to be worth millions: why do so many employers never see the direct-contracting options actually available to them? The answer is hidden in the database, in the methodology and the data that quietly decide what makes it onto the menu. 

Affordability is a determinant of health 

Northwell has long taken a broad view of its responsibility, from gun violence to food insecurity to education, and concluded that affordability belongs on that list too. When insurance costs so much that people can’t afford to use it, that’s a health problem, not just a benefits problem. As the largest provider and largest employer in New York, Northwell faces the same math on its own plan, and built a real business around the answer: 60 people whose only job is this, not something run off the side of a desk. 

“If you’re going to do this, you’ve got to really do it. You can’t take responsibility for somebody’s health plan and screw it up.” 

The commitment shows up in the numbers: more than 300,000 members across 80-plus employers and unions, roughly $2.5 billion in medical spend, and over $100 million in savings since their first health-plan client in July 2022. 

The 20% nobody believes 

Direct contracting routinely delivers around a 20% savings differential against the traditional model, yet it still fails the sniff test, because surely a regional partner can’t beat a national carrier’s deal. The fix isn’t a better slide; it’s data. Take an employer’s own historical claims and reprice them through the direct network, and the 20% shows up in their own numbers. That’s why every employer and advisor should be beating the drum to get their claims data, and why some carriers hold it back as a quiet retention play. As Todor added, the real edge isn’t just the average discount. 98% of utilization barely matters; it’s the 2% of members on catastrophic journeys driving half your claims and most of your volatility, and a direct relationship gives you visibility into exactly those cases, where a PPO loses them in the average. 

“If you’re not doing steerage, somebody else is doing it for your patients inside that PPO network.” 

Quality, the human definition 

We spend a lot of energy on the technical definition of quality: star ratings, variation, outcomes. All fair. But there’s also the human one. If my kid is sick, can I get them in, quickly, with someone I trust? That’s where integration matters. Northwell wraps care management connected to where you actually get care, so members pick up the phone, because it isn’t a stranger calling about a bill, and backs it with navigators who have full scheduling access across the network. No traditional insurer can book you directly into a provider’s calendar. One member at a large Dallas–Fort Worth employer said it better than any of us could: 

“I don’t have to worry about anything on this plan, except investing in myself.” 

2028 feels different 

“Costs are out of control” is not news. What feels different is the pressure, and the exhaustion of the usual tools. Plan-design tweaks are tapped out. The point-solution explosion has left employers with a fragmented ecosystem and a trend still running 10 to 15%, wondering what they bought. Nobody expects 40% of employers to tear everything up next year, but both Nick and Todor see adoption accelerating. Todor’s advice: stop waiting for the bad renewal or the mandated RFP, and make it a habit to look, because there are more real alternatives in the market than there have ever been. Just be clear-eyed separating the real thing from the marketing. Everyone claims 10 to 20%, but only solutions that actually change unit cost and coordinate care deliver it. The best consultants earn their keep matching the right solution to the right employer. 

Nick’s closing advice was blunt and correct: start with the data, at a granular level, and use it to open a conversation with providers. You’ll be surprised how many are ready. I’ll leave you with a line from a Dallas–Fort Worth meeting with our partner Baylor Scott & White, where someone opened by saying the traditional carrier’s whole role was to make sure the employer and the provider never talked to each other. The magic starts the moment they do. 

The blind spot was never that good options don’t exist. It’s that the standard way of looking won’t show them to you. So change how you look. 

Watch the full conversation with Nick Stefanizzi and Todor Penev on demand here. 

– Ashok Subramanian